Next: Conclusive Reasons Condition
Up: Counter-Counter Arguments
Previous: No False Belief Condition
One attempt is that of Alvin Goldman, who puts forth a theory
of causal connection between knowledge of propositions. Goldman states that
persons A knows that X if and only if the fact X is causally connected in an
``appropriate'' way with A's believing that X. What he defines as appropriate
is a combination of perception, memory, and a causal chain of events that is
correctly constructed through warranted inferences.
In other words, for someone to know something, it must be related
to something else that such a person knew in a certain way. This seems
quite vague and broad blanketed. Hence the reason why Goldman's condition
does not appear to solve the perceptual Gettier-type problem illustrated
above with Mrs. Knull.
E R
2000-06-13